Under the guise of protecting businesses and personal information, the politicians in Westchester County, New York,
have decided to try passing a law trying to force businesses and home offices to secure their wireless networks.
Politicians in Westchester County are urging adoption of the law--which appears to be the first such legislation in the U.S.--because without it, "somebody parked in the street or sitting in a neighboring building could hack into the network and steal your most confidential data," County Executive Andy Spano said in a statement.
The draft proposal offered this week would compel all "commercial businesses" with an open wireless access point to have a "network gateway server" outfitted with a software or hardware firewall. Such a firewall, used to block intrusions from outside the local network, would be required even for a coffee shop that used an old-fashioned cash register instead of an Internet-linked credit card system that could be vulnerable to intrusions.
I'd like to say this sounds good in theory, but after the slightest bit of consideration it's easy to see that this is not a good law. Not only is it restrictive of a service for which people pay, but how do they plan to enforce it? They're going to send police patrols wardriving into upscale neighborhoods with home offices, when real actual crime goes on elsewhere?
Don't even get me started on regulating how a business or person decides to use his or her Internet. If I want to run an AP wide open so that anyone parked outside can use it, I should be allowed to, even if I do run a business from home. The government shouldn't legislate me into buying more equipment to do so. It's my money, my service and my network.
If they're trying this for some sort of warning to the public at large, regarding the insecurity of their wireless APs, then there's a better and more legitimate way to do it. That's called the Public Service Announcement. "Lock down your wireless." There. That's catchy enough. Run radio ads, run TV ads, run paper ads, but for God's sake, don't bring the law into it.
Absolutely ridiculous.